Potter’s Field to Parade Ground: The Beginnings of WSP

January 4 2022

January is an important month for Washington Square Park. Not because anything necessarily grand or exciting happens during this chilly month. No. What makes the date important is what happened at a Common Council Meeting in 1826.

It was newly elected Mayor Philip Hone’s first Common Council meeting, and Alderman Abraham Valentine introduced a resolution to re-appropriate an old potter’s field into a military parade ground. Up until that moment, the area we now call Washington Square Park served a very different purpose for the city of New York. From 1797 until May of 1825, the land was used as a potter’s field – a public burial ground where poor and indigent people, many victims of yellow fever, were laid to rest. When the potter’s field was first established at the end of the 18th century it was on land considered to be the city outskirts. By 1823 however, the neighborhood around the field had changed significantly. What had once been a sparsely populated was no longer the sparsely populated suburb was quickly becoming the hottest neighborhood around. Real estate boomed and new constructions sprang up, creating a sharp contrast against the field. Shops opened and many new residents made their homes in the area despite the nearby burial ground.

The city’s population had exploded, growing from about 33,000 in 1790 to 124,000 by 1820, and every available plot of land was needed for development. These people needed places to live, and that demand had caused the price of land to skyrocket. But the burial ground was physically too unstable to support commercial or private development, so it was useless from a construction standpoint. However it could be turned into open land for residents to enjoy. 

Seventh Regiment on Review, Washington Square, New York, 1851, Otto Boetticher. The view depicts the northwest corner of the Washington Square parade ground with New York University in the left foreground. Image courtesy of the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

A pleasant green space had the potential to lure wealthy homeowners and could increase property values (and property taxes) in the surrounding area. Even better, costs for improving the new space could be covered by levying special assessments on neighboring lots that were more appropriate for development.

When Alderman Valentine’s resolution passed six weeks after its introduction, planning began for the new parade ground. It was set to open with much pomp and circumstance on July 4, 1826. Dubbed the Washington Military Parade Ground, the public space was a hit from day one. About 50,000 people attended the Parade Ground’s inauguration jubilee, about ⅓ of the city’s population at the time. And it only took a few months for eight landowners to construct 12 homes on the southwest side of the Park, quickly lending the neighborhood an air of respectability. 

1850 plan of the Park, courtesy of NYC Parks

The borders of the Parade Ground are the same as Washington Square Park’s borders today, but the interior looked quite different. The early layout was rigidly symmetrical and full of straight lines – appropriate for practicing military reviews and drills. After the Ground officially opened the city spent the next few months levying assessments to pay for greater improvements. While it was formally intended as a parade ground – and indeed, volunteer regiments did use it to perform drills – by 1827 it was generally recognized as a public park. And the improvements the city made reflected this shift.

New plantings were added and walkways were added to make the area more welcoming and inviting to residents. The Evening Post (which eventually became The New York Post) described these changes in their May 10, 1828 edition: “Workmen are busily employed putting a handsome fence around this spacious public square…and laborers are busy leveling and preparing the ground to be laid down to green turf with neat gravel foot walks around the margin and across it from each extremity. When this work is completed and proper shade trees and shrubbery are hopefully set out over the whole square, it will afford a most delightful morning promenade.”

Now decidedly looking the part of “Park,” it would still take a few more decades for WSP to gain its iconic monuments. The first fountain was placed in the center of the Park in 1852 (to be replaced by the current fountain in the 1870’s renovation spearheaded by the Commissioner of the newly created NYC Parks Department, William “Boss” Tweed). The Garibaldi and Holley monuments were placed in 1888 and 1890, respectively. And perhaps the most iconic monument, the Arch, didn’t appear on the scene until 1892. But still, even without these familiar features, it was our Park. Which means that even today, when you step inside Washington Square Park’s fence and stroll along the paths or sit on a bench, you’re appreciating the space the same way that New Yorkers have for nearly 200 years.